Reaction paper on being sane in insane places

While I was imprisoned and trapped in that madhouse I learned a lot of things and get this - I overcame the labels. It requires constant awareness of my situation, critical thinking, patience, perseverance, strength, will power, and a strategy. I took all of their tests, and the psychologist told me I "cheated" on them. I asked him "why did you tell me there was no wrong answers than?

Reaction paper on being sane in insane places

Powerlessness and depersonalisation were noticeable in the ways in which the patients were deprived of several human rights such as liberty of motion and privateness.


Medical records were open to al workers regardless of position or therapeutic relationship with the patient and personal hygiene was watched and many of the toilets did not have doors. A number of the ward orderlies would be brutal to patients in full view of other patients but would stop when another staff member approached.

This mentioned that staff were credible witnesses but patients were not. It was approximated that the pseudo patients received a total of 2, medication tablets, though only two were swallowed. The others were either pocketed or flushed down the toilet.

Often, when the pseudo patients stopped at the toilets to dispose of their tablets they found the medication of other patients that got already been positioned there. So long as the patients were co-operative, then their behavior went unnoticed.

The files the pseudo patients experienced made about the amount of time the nurses stayed in the ward offices was about 90 per cent of the time and the number of times medical staff arrived onto the ward, and the amount of time put in with psychiatrists, psychologists, registrars etc was, typically, under seven minutes each day.

Home - AlmaCleanAlmaClean

Staff members were asked to rate on a point range each new patient as to the likelihood of them being truly a pseudo patient. This fake information was the manipulated unbiased variable, and the centered variable was the amount of patients which staff subsequently suspected to be pseudo patients.

Judgement of all admissions patients as to the likelihood they are pseudo patients Number of patients judged Number of patients confidently judged as pseudo patients by at least one personnel member 41 Number of patients suspected by one psychiatrist 23 Number of patients suspected by one psychiatrist AND an added staff member 19 Explanation Rosenhan promises that the study shows that psychiatrists cannot reliably tell the difference between people who are sane and the ones who are insane.

The main test illustrated a failure to detect sanity, and the secondary study demonstrated a failure to identify insanity. Rosenhan explains that psychiatric brands tend to stick in a way that medical labels do not which everything a patient will is interpreted relative to the diagnostic label once it's been applied.

He suggested that instead of labelling a person as crazy we should focus on the individual's specific problems and behaviours. Evaluation of the Procedure Strengths The participant observation recommended that the pseudo patients could go through the ward from the patients' perspective while also retaining some degree of objectivity.

The study was a type of field experiment and was thus quite ecologically valid whilst still handling to regulate many variables including the pseudo patients' behavior. Rosenhan used a variety of hospitals.

This enables the leads to be generalised. Weaknesses The hospital personnel was deceived - this is, of course, unethical. Although Rosenhan did not conceal the titles of hospitals or personnel and attemptedto eliminate any signs which might lead with their identification Rosenhan did remember that the encounters of the pseudo-patients can have differed from that of real patients who did not contain the comfort of knowing that the medical diagnosis was wrong.

Perhaps Rosenhan was being too much on psychiatric clinics, especially when it's important to allow them to play safe in their prognosis of abnormality since there is always an outcry when a patient is let out of psychiatric good care and enters trouble.

If you were to visit the doctors complaining of belly aches how would you expect to be cured?

Reaction paper on being sane in insane places

Doctors and psychiatrists will make a sort two error that is, more likely to call a healthy person sick and tired when compared to a type one error that is, diagnosing a sick and tired person as healthy When Rosenhan performed his research the psychiatric classification in use was DSM-II.

However, since then a fresh classification has been unveiled which was to address itself basically to the complete problem of unreliability - especially unclear conditions. It is argued that with the newer classification DSM-III, launched in the s, psychiatrists would be less inclined to make the errors they did.

The DSM happens to be in its fourth model DSM-IV Evaluation of Explanation The study demonstrates both the limitations of classification and importantly the appalling conditions in many psychiatric hospitals. This has stimulated much further research and has lead to numerous institutions improving their philosophy of care.

Rosenhan, like other anti-psychiatrists, is arguing that mental illness is a public phenomenon. It really is simply a outcome of labelling.In his essay, On Being Sane in Insane Places, D. L. Rosenhan discusses a series of experiments that he participated in involving psychiatric institutions and the effect of misdiagnoses of psychological disorders on the patients admitted to the hospitals.

Popular Questions

Rosenhan’s research shows us that the labels associated with mental illness . Get an answer for 'What is the thesis of David Rosenhan's famous research paper "on being sane in insane places"?be specific' and find homework help for other Social Sciences questions at /what-thesis-being-sane-insane-places  · lets of paper in such public places as the day-room.

No secret was made of these activities. The pseudopatient, very much as a true psy- Being Sane in Insane Places pseudopatient's simulation. Nor are there any indications in the hospital records that the pseudopatient's status was suspect.

Opening Skinner's Box: Paper on Chapter 3, on Being Sane in Insane Places - Essay

Rather, Rosenhan Being sane in. · On Being Sane in Insane Places by David L. Rosenhan Originally published in Science, New Series, Vol. , No. (Jan. 19, ), pp. the question of whether the sane can be distinguished from the insane (and whether degrees of insanity can be distinguished from they were subsequently written on standard tablets of paper in Terveenä.

· On Being Insane in Sane Places essays Just how insane or sane is sanity? Is it possible to tell a sane person from someone that is insane? How is it that one psychiatrist can testify that a person is insane, while another equally qualified one argues that they are sane?

Obviously, notions of  · I will use help from online sources and material given in class (slide about D.L. Rosenhan, , on being sane in insane places.) given by the lecturer to help me develop ideas and reach a good conclusion and understanding of the questions

Opening Skinner’s Box Causes Controversy – Association for Psychological Science